A gallon of propane, a therm of natural gas, a gallon of heating oil, and a kilowatt-hour of electricity each contain a different amount of heat. Comparing their prices directly tells you almost nothing. The fair way to compare them is the cost of one million Btu of heat delivered into your house.

Step 1: price per million Btu of fuel

A British thermal unit (Btu) is the heat needed to warm one pound of water by one degree Fahrenheit. One million Btu (written MMBtu) is a convenient block: a typical cold-climate house uses somewhere between 40 and 100 MMBtu of heat in a winter. The U.S. Energy Information Administration publishes typical heat contents for each fuel:

FuelHeat per unitUnits in 1 MMBtu
Natural gas100,000 Btu/therm10 therms
Propane91,452 Btu/gal10.9 gallons
Heating oil (No. 2)138,500 Btu/gal7.2 gallons
Electricity3,412 Btu/kWh293 kWh
Firewood (seasoned hardwood)~20 million Btu/cord0.05 cord
Wood pellets~16.5 million Btu/ton0.06 ton

So the price of the fuel itself, per million Btu, is:

price per unit × 1,000,000 ÷ Btu per unit

Propane at $2.50 a gallon works out to $2.50 × 1,000,000 ÷ 91,452 = $27.34 per MMBtu of fuel.

Step 2: adjust for equipment efficiency

No furnace turns all of its fuel into heat in your rooms. A furnace's AFUE rating tells you the seasonal share it does capture: an 80% AFUE furnace sends about 20% up the flue. Electric resistance heat is 100% efficient at the point of use. A heat pump moves heat from outdoors instead of making it, so it delivers more heat than the electricity it uses; that ratio is its coefficient of performance (COP). Divide by the efficiency to get the cost of delivered heat:

cost per MMBtu delivered = price per unit × 1,000,000 ÷ (Btu per unit × efficiency)

The same $2.50 propane in a 95% furnace costs $27.34 ÷ 0.95 = $28.78 per MMBtu delivered. In an old 65% furnace it costs $42.06, which is why replacing very old equipment can matter as much as switching fuels. More on AFUE and COP.

Step 3: multiply by your heat load

Cost per MMBtu ranks the fuels. To get dollars per year, multiply by how many MMBtu your house needs. If you heated with 900 therms of gas last winter in a 95% furnace, your house used 900 × 0.1 × 0.95 = 85.5 MMBtu of heat. That number stays the same whichever fuel you use, so it is the bridge between fuels.

Where U.S. averages stand now

Using EIA's national residential averages (propane and heating oil for the week of November 16, 2026; natural gas over the last heating season; electricity year to date), and typical equipment:

OptionPriceEfficiency$/MMBtu delivered
Natural gas$1.43/therm95% furnace$15.09
Air-source heat pump18.2¢/kWhCOP 2.5$21.32
Propane$2.82/gal95% furnace$32.42
Heating oil$5.72/gal85% boiler$48.56
Electric baseboard18.2¢/kWh100%$53.31
U.S. averages hide big state differences. See prices by state.

What this comparison leaves out

  • Equipment and installation. Switching fuels can cost thousands of dollars. Running cost is only half of the decision.
  • Fixed charges. A gas hookup has a monthly customer charge whether you use gas or not; a propane tank may carry a rental fee or minimum-delivery rule.
  • Price swings. Propane and heating oil can move sharply within one winter; utility rates change less often.
  • Heat pump performance in cold weather. COP falls as outdoor temperatures drop, so use a seasonal figure for your climate, not the best-case rating.

The calculator does all three steps for you, with your state's prices pre-filled.